Shiloh/Credibility

February 10, 2012: Damon Confirms Shiloh Cheated and Apologizes to Onision

On February 10, 2012, Damon—Shiloh’s former music producer—told Onision he was glad Onision finally saw “the truth,” apologized that Shiloh had cheated, and confirmed that Onision had previously been warned about her conduct.

On February 10, 2012, Onision contacted Damon, Shiloh’s former music producer, after receiving evidence that Shiloh had cheated on him.

Onision explained that Shiloh had previously told him Damon accused her of cheating during a writing camp:

“Shiloh told me a while back you said she cheated on me when she went with you guys to the writing camp — I automatically wrote it off as if it were nothing...”

Onision stated that he had since received evidence confirming the infidelity:

“I was finally given irrefutable evidence that she cheated on me recently”

He apologized to Damon for initially refusing to believe the warning:

“You, my mom, my sisters & so many others were 100% right”

“I just want to say sorry for not believing you, repeatedly questioning your honesty.”

Damon replied:

“dude, i am glad you finally see the truth”

He then wrote:

“i am sorry that she cheated on you”

Damon also apologized for jokes he had made at Onision’s expense, stated that he still thought about Onision, and wished him happiness.

What the Evidence Establishes

The exchange provides contemporaneous third-party corroboration of Onision’s account concerning Shiloh’s dishonesty and infidelity.

It records that:

• Damon had warned Onision that Shiloh cheated during a writing camp (a different incident).
• Onision initially dismissed the accusation and continued believing Shiloh.
• Onision’s mother, sisters, and other people had also warned him.
• Later evidence caused Onision to recognize that those warnings were accurate.
• Damon confirmed the underlying issue by saying Onision finally saw “the truth.”
• Damon expressly apologized that Shiloh had cheated.
• Damon apologized for his own past treatment of Onision and wished him well.

The chronology shows that Onision was not looking for reasons to attack Shiloh. He initially defended her, rejected warnings from multiple people, and questioned the honesty of those attempting to tell him what had occurred.

Only after receiving confirming evidence did he accept that Shiloh had deceived him.

This exchange strengthens Onision’s longstanding explanation for ending the relationship and removing Shiloh from his life. It also predates the later interviews, fundraising activity, and media portrayals in which Shiloh framed Onision as the dishonest or abusive party.

Source

Email exchange between Onision and Damon dated February 10, 2012.

The sender’s email address has been redacted in the published screenshot.

Related: The Shiloh Record · Claimed Harm and Damages · Damage to Onision and Lucas

July 7, 2012: Shiloh Contacts Onision After the Breakup and Wishes Him Happiness

On July 7, 2012, months after the relationship had ended, Shiloh contacted him to express pride in his work and wish him a happy, healthy life, completely contradicting her later account.

On July 7, 2012, Shiloh sent Onision an unsolicited email after their relationship had ended in February 2012 in part as the result of Shiloh cheating on Onision and becoming pregnant with another man's baby.

She wrote:

“I’m really proud of your video quality, I just wanted you to know that.”

“I hope you are living a happy healthy life, and continue to make funny videos.”

The email was warm, supportive, and directed toward Onision’s future happiness and continued success, this is not compatible with Shiloh's later changed story.

Post-Breakup Context

Onision has consistently stated that he ended the relationship after discovering serious deception, infidelity, financial misconduct, and that Shiloh had become pregnant by another man.

He has also stated that he stopped communicating with her and repeatedly attempted to remove her from his life.

The July 2012 email fits that chronology. Shiloh was the person initiating contact, praising Onision’s work, and wishing him well after he had already moved on.

The inbox visible beneath the message also contains multiple additional Shiloh-related email threads, further documenting continued communication.

What the Evidence Establishes

Years after the relationship, Shiloh publicly portrayed Onision as a dangerous and abusive figure while participating in hostile interviews, fundraising activity, and Onision: In Real Life.

Her contemporaneous conduct was materially different.

After the relationship had ended, Shiloh:

• continued contacting Onision
• expressed pride in his creative work
• wished him a happy and healthy life
• encouraged him to continue producing videos
• used friendly and affectionate language rather than fear, hostility, or avoidance

This message supports Onision’s account that he was attempting to end the relationship and move forward while Shiloh continued seeking contact and involvement in his life despite her later changed position that he was somehow someone she would never want to contact in such a way.

It also creates a major chronological problem for Shiloh’s later public narrative. Her later characterization of Onision changed dramatically, but this post-breakup message records how she actually addressed him when no documentary, donation campaign, or anti-Onision media opportunity was involved.

Source

Email from Shiloh dated July 7, 2012, preserved through a screenshot of the receiving email account.

The image also shows several additional Shiloh-related email threads in the surrounding inbox.

Related: The Shiloh Record · Claimed Harm and Damages · Damage to Onision and Lucas

August 2020: Shiloh Accuses Her Anti-Onision Allies of Lies and Is Accused of Lying in Return

August 2020 posts show the anti-Onision coalition turning against itself: Shiloh accused women she had called “sisters” of spreading lies and rumors, while other participants accused Shiloh and Regina of dishonesty and misconduct.

In August 2020, the group of accusers and supporters publicly campaigning against Onision began accusing one another of dishonesty and misconduct.

Shiloh wrote:

“Very hurt to see now that those I called sisters are stabbing me in the back with lies and rumors.”

She added that she had placed herself “in the line of fire” to protect them, had respected their wishes, and was withdrawing from the group.

The statement is significant because Shiloh herself characterized people previously presented as fellow victims and allies as spreading “lies and rumors.”

Shiloh Is Accused of Lying

A separate participant wrote:

“I deleted because Shiloh lied and said she didn’t do it but we just got confirmation that she did so this tweet still stands”

The same period also produced public criticism directed at both Shiloh and Regina. A post shown as retweeted by Billie stated:

“What Shiloh and Regina did is disgusting. Period.”

Sarah also publicly named Shiloh during the dispute, reflecting the collapse of the public alliance among people who had previously appeared together against Onision.

What the Record Establishes

These posts document that the anti-Onision campaign was not composed of witnesses consistently confirming one another’s accounts.

Instead, its own participants publicly alleged that:

• former allies were spreading lies and rumors
• Shiloh denied conduct that others said had been confirmed
• Shiloh and Regina had engaged in behavior their own allies considered “disgusting”
• the supposed unified group had fractured into competing and hostile factions

This directly supports Onision’s longstanding account that several people removed from his life were dishonest and later turned against one another.

The importance is not merely that the group had a personal disagreement. These people had been promoted publicly as mutually credible accusers while participating in interviews, sharing fundraising and donation links, supporting the campaign that removed Onision from platforms, and contributing to the media environment surrounding Onision: In Real Life.

Once the alliance collapsed, the same participants began using the language Onision had used for years: lying, rumors, denial, betrayal, and concealed conduct.

Their later accusations against one another materially weaken the appearance that the campaign consisted of independent witnesses consistently corroborating the same reliable narrative. The record instead shows a coalition whose members publicly disputed each other’s honesty after benefiting from collective attention and opposition to Onision.

Media and Financial Context

The internal dispute occurred while anti-Onision content was generating substantial attention through social media, donation campaigns, Chris Hansen interviews, and documentary production.

That context created incentives for participants to maintain a unified public narrative. Their subsequent public breakdown is therefore especially probative: once their interests diverged, accusations of dishonesty emerged from inside the same group that had previously been portrayed as mutually supportive and credible.

Shiloh’s own statement is particularly consequential. She was not merely being accused of lying by Onision. She was accusing her fellow anti-Onision participants of spreading lies and rumors while simultaneously being accused of dishonesty by people within that same network.

Source

Composite of social-media posts circulated around August 7, 2020.

The image includes:

• a statement attributed to Shiloh
• a post accusing Shiloh of lying
• a post from Sarah naming Shiloh during the dispute
• a screenshot showing Billie retweeting criticism of Shiloh and Regina

The surrounding headings and concluding commentary are editorial annotations included in the composite image.

Related: Shiloh: Claimed Harm and Damages · Damage to Onision and Lucas · Sarah’s Public Accusations